The Comfort of Catastrophizing

Hoping for a good outcome requires sitting with genuine uncertainty and uncertainty, held over time, can be harder to bear than a known bad one. This episode looks at why imagining the worst can feel, in a strange way, safer than staying open to the best; not as a flaw in thinking, but as a coherent trade the nervous system makes between an unbearable open feeling and a bearable closed one. If you’ve ever found yourself bracing for something that hadn’t happened yet, this is a conversation about what that bracing is actually doing, and what it quietly costs.


AI Generated Transcript:

Someone is waiting to hear back about something important — a job result, a medical test, an answer from someone they care about. And in the silence before the answer arrives, their mind doesn’t drift toward the best-case scenario. It goes, almost immediately, to the worst one. Not briefly — it sets up camp there. It rehearses what the bad news will sound like, how they’ll react, what they’ll do next. And here’s the strange part: if you asked that person whether they’d prefer to feel this way, they’d almost certainly say no. And yet, something about going there feels less like falling into a trap, and more like… arriving somewhere familiar. Somewhere that, in some odd way, feels safer than the alternative.

I’m Andrei Barburas, and this is The Unlearning Project — a podcast from barburas.com, where every couple of weeks we take one assumption that usually goes unexamined and we crack it open. Today’s assumption is about hope and worry — specifically, the assumption that hoping for a good outcome is the more “positive,” and therefore the more comfortable, mental state, while imagining the worst is simply unpleasant, something we’d avoid if we could. For a lot of people, it’s actually the other way around. And once you understand why, catastrophizing stops looking like a flaw in someone’s thinking, and starts looking like something closer to a strategy — a not particularly effective one, but a strategy nonetheless.

Let’s start with what hope actually requires, psychologically, because this is where the asymmetry begins.

Hoping for a good outcome means holding open the possibility that something you want will happen — and not knowing yet whether it will. That’s the structure of hope: a desired future, combined with genuine uncertainty about whether it’ll arrive. And uncertainty, held over time, particularly about something that matters, is genuinely uncomfortable. Not because uncertainty is inherently bad — but because as long as the outcome is unknown, there’s nothing to do with the feeling. You can’t process it, resolve it, or move past it. It just sits there, unresolved, for however long the uncertainty lasts.

Catastrophizing — imagining the worst-case outcome, in detail, often repeatedly — does something different with that uncertainty. It doesn’t resolve it either, not really. But it feels like it does, because it replaces an open question with a specific, vivid scenario. Instead of “I don’t know what’s going to happen,” the mind generates “here’s what’s going to happen, and it’s bad, and here’s exactly how bad.” That’s not actually more information than before — the real outcome is just as unknown as it was a moment ago. But emotionally, it can feel like a kind of resolution, because there’s now a concrete picture to react to, rather than an empty space where a picture should be.

This is, I think, the core of why catastrophizing can feel comforting, even though “comforting” seems like the wrong word for imagining disaster. It’s not that the disaster itself is comforting. It’s that having something specific — even something terrible — can feel more manageable than having nothing, when “nothing” is actually “an open question I have no control over.”

There’s a related piece of this worth naming, which is about control. Hoping for a good outcome, particularly one that depends heavily on factors outside your control — someone else’s decision, a result that’s already been determined and just hasn’t been communicated yet, an event that hasn’t happened — puts you in a position of waiting. And waiting, especially waiting for something you can’t influence, can feel like a particularly powerless state. Catastrophizing offers something that feels like an exit from that powerlessness — not by giving you actual control over the outcome, but by giving you something to do in the meantime. You can rehearse. You can prepare. You can mentally “get ahead of it.” Even if “getting ahead of it” doesn’t actually change anything about what’s coming, it produces a feeling of activity, which can feel meaningfully different from the feeling of helplessly waiting.

This connects to something worth bringing in here — the way the nervous system responds to anticipated threat versus unpredictable threat. There’s a reasonable body of research suggesting that, in many cases, a known negative outcome can be less distressing, physiologically, than an unknown outcome that could go either way. This seems almost backwards at first — surely a guaranteed bad outcome is worse than a possible good one? But the nervous system isn’t really evaluating outcomes in that way. It’s evaluating predictability. And unpredictability, for a system that’s fundamentally oriented around anticipating and responding to threat, registers as its own kind of danger — sometimes more acutely than a predictable negative does.

So catastrophizing, in a strange way, can function as a way of trading an unpredictable situation for a predictable one — even though the predictable one it lands on is bad. The mind isn’t choosing “bad” over “good.” It’s choosing “known” over “unknown” — and for a nervous system wired around threat detection, known often wins, even when known is worse.

There’s another layer to this that I think is particularly important, and it has to do with disappointment — specifically, the anticipation of disappointment.

If you allow yourself to genuinely hope for something — to sit with the possibility that it’ll go well, without hedging — and then it doesn’t go well, the gap between what you’d allowed yourself to hope for and what actually happened becomes part of the disappointment itself. Catastrophizing can function as a kind of pre-emptive narrowing of that gap. If you’ve already, mentally, lived through the bad outcome — rehearsed it, prepared for it, in some sense already grieved it — then if it actually happens, there’s less distance to fall. You’ve already been there. It’s not new information arriving into a space that was full of hope; it’s confirmation of something you’d already, in some sense, made peace with.

The cost, of course, is that this preparation happens regardless of what actually occurs. If the good outcome happens instead — and often it does, more often than the catastrophic rehearsal would suggest — the person doesn’t get to retroactively recover all the time and energy spent bracing for something that never arrived. The bracing was real, even if the thing it was bracing against wasn’t. In trying to minimize the potential pain of one specific outcome, catastrophizing ends up distributing a smaller, more diffuse pain across the entire period of uncertainty — regardless of how that uncertainty eventually resolves.

I think this is worth sitting with, because it reframes catastrophizing not as “negative thinking” in some vague moral sense, but as a kind of trade. A trade that exchanges a possible, larger, but uncertain future pain, for a smaller, but certain, present one — the discomfort of sitting with the catastrophic scenario, now, in exchange for feeling slightly more prepared, slightly less blindsided, if and when things go badly.

The problem with this trade isn’t that it’s irrational — given how the nervous system processes predictability and threat, it’s actually a fairly coherent response, in its own internal logic. The problem is that the trade gets made every time, regardless of the actual odds — which means, over a lifetime, someone who catastrophizes habitually ends up paying that smaller, present cost constantly, for outcomes that, statistically, mostly don’t end up being catastrophic at all. The “insurance” gets purchased over and over, even in situations where the thing being insured against was never particularly likely.

There’s also something worth saying about how catastrophizing can function socially, not just internally — because this is something that often goes unnoticed. Expressing the worst-case scenario out loud, to other people, can sometimes serve a kind of social purpose: it can pre-emptively lower other people’s expectations, so that if things do go badly, there’s no additional layer of “I told you it would be fine” to navigate. It can also, sometimes, function as a way of inviting reassurance — saying the catastrophic version out loud and having someone push back against it (“no, I really think it’ll be fine”) can provide a kind of comfort that simply thinking the same reassurance to yourself doesn’t quite provide, because it’s coming from outside, from someone who isn’t — in that moment — the one who needs it to be true.

So where does this leave us? I don’t think the goal here is to simply tell people to “think positively instead” — that kind of advice tends to skate right past the actual mechanism we’ve just walked through, and in some ways it can make things worse, because it frames the catastrophic thinking as a simple choice that’s just being made badly, rather than as a response to something real — the discomfort of genuine uncertainty, and the nervous system’s strong preference for predictability over openness.

I think what’s more useful is something closer to naming the trade as it’s happening. Not “stop imagining the worst” — but noticing, in the moment, that what’s happening is an attempt to convert an unbearable open feeling into a more bearable closed one, even at the cost of the closed one being bad. Once that’s visible, there’s at least a choice available that wasn’t visible before: is this particular uncertainty one where the trade is worth making — or is this a situation where staying with the openness, uncomfortable as it is, might actually serve better than pre-emptively closing it with something painful, just for the relief of having something to hold onto?

Here’s the question I want to leave you with. Think of something in your life right now that you’re genuinely uncertain about — something where you don’t yet know how it’ll turn out. And notice: is your mind currently sitting with that uncertainty, openly? Or has it already quietly resolved it, on its own, into a version where it goes badly — not because that’s the most likely outcome, but because a bad, known outcome was easier to hold than a good, unknown one?

That’s it for this episode of The Unlearning Project. We’ll be back in two weeks with another one. Until then, notice what your mind reaches for, when it doesn’t yet know what’s coming.

Get the BARBURAS Insights in your mailbox
You may also like